Squire Ale House

Came here having no prior experience with the original restaurant or the Rookies restaurants. Pros - Atmosphere when we went (around opening/4pm) was very welcoming - Food felt filling but not greasey. We got the cheese curds which were battered in house amd they were some of the best we ever had. I had the Chicken Pub sandwich, grilled, with no tomato. Was very flavorful and delicious. Neither food made me feel sick when we got home. - Seats were surprisingly comfortable since we sat at a high top. Cushioning made it easier to relax and talk. - Wait staff and bartender were really kind the whole time. It felt like they went out of their way to be courteous. - Thw craft soda selection. If you come here, def try the Green River. Haven't had a lime soda that tasted as good. Con (only 1) - Prices for non alcoholic drinks could be made clearer on the menu Even though its a bit of a drive from home, it was worth the travel and price.

We started out with the buffalo rotisserie wings, which were excellent. Our server recommended the steak house sandwich, and it was delicious. The tater kegs are an absolute must ... I mean, literally the best !!! My only complaint was that the manager on duty was less than accommodating, and her people skills were extremely sub-par. It's pretty sad when the hostess has to apologize for the managers behavior.

We love the Village Squire and were excited to try this restaurant. Loved everything! We got the Red Ale which was delicious. The appetizers (calamari, cheese curds and pretzels) were gone as soon as served. And dinner was outstanding! Highly recommend!!

My husband and I have dined in 2x since they opened in March. Both times we have absolutely loved the food and service! We love that there is a large menu with plenty to choose from, the fact that the food is fresh, and that the portions are just right! We have even had a chance to meet the chef who makes it a point to go out and greet the customers!! The staff is very welcoming and friendly! If you get a chance to dine there, ask for Cynthia, she is the best!! We will continue to make the drive out to enjoy more meals with Squire Ale House!! Five stars

We’re frequent diners at Village Squire South Elgin. We know the Squire family of restaurants have quality from our experiences - so wanted to give this new launch location a try choosing an off time 4pm on Sunday. The front entry was packed with people and there was confusion with who had checked in at front desk & were still waiting to be seated vs who was still waiting to check in at desk. The gal running the front desk was very young and while trying her best, it would be best a far more seasoned staff member control this area for now and keep things moving rapidly and organized. We were seated readily after the 3 parties totaling 21 people were seated. The left side of the restaurant where the bar is located is comprised of a few booths - high tops and primarily what I’d call counter height tables. Took quite a while before our server stopped by. Decided to try a menu item not offered at Village Squire - the ahi tuna salad. It was FANTASTIC ! I subbed out the dressing for the Greek feta dressing as it’s my FAV. Broasted chicken is only offered Sunday thru Tuesday so we also chose that item which was yummy. I had a Squire Red ale which was delicious. Price points for menu entrees for higher tier items in common with Village Squire (salmon - prime rib etc) are definitely 10% or more higher price. Guessing the restaurants costs have risen quite a bit but it’s not warranted increasing the prices yet at VILLAGE Squire. $75 for two before tip for a casual Sunday afternoon meal (calamari / broasted chicken / ahi tuna salad / 1 red squire beer / 1 iced tea) - no regrets - but no desire to return to dine there. We will stick with Village Squire.

Food and service was spectacular. I had the Shrimp Scampi Pasta like dish (they call it something else), but it was wonderful. Good drinks as well. Very nice place and cool bathrooms as the kids said